Why employees don't trust engagement surveys, and what actually helps
Daniele D'Esposito, Founder, Org360
, 9 min read
This article looks at why so many employees dislike engagement surveys and hold back the truth when they fill them in, what HR experts suggest doing about it, and how we approached the problem in Org360. It started at a tech conference in Berlin, where people told us, unprompted, that they hate these surveys: busy work, never anonymous, and nothing changes anyway. So we checked whether the data backs them up. It does.
In plain English
Nearly half of employees feel pressured to hold back feedback in engagement surveys. The two main reasons are that they don't believe the survey is really anonymous, and they don't believe anything will change. Only 8% of employees strongly agree their organization acts on survey results.
Experts agree on the main fix: act on what people say, and show it. They also suggest collecting fewer personal details and using tools that can't trace answers back. Our own answer is a confidentiality mode where the survey owner never reads a single comment, only an AI summary, because comments are where people get recognized.
The problem, in numbers
- 47% of employees say they often or occasionally feel pressured to hold back feedback in engagement surveys, according to a Visier survey of 1,000 US employees in October 2024.
- Among those who aren't always honest, the top reason, given by 37%, is that they don't believe engagement surveys are ever really anonymous. The second, at 27%, is that they don't believe their employer will act on their feedback.
- Only 8% of employees strongly agree that their organization takes action on surveys, according to Gallup.
- In Perceptyx's benchmark data, drawing on more than 12 million employee responses, only 8% of organizations that surveyed without following up saw engagement rise over three years. Among those that acted, 74% did.
"Anonymous" is the punchline
Distrust of survey anonymity is so common it has become a genre of workplace humor.
- A meme that keeps coming back on Instagram and TikTok shows employees being escorted out of the building, captioned "Me being escorted out of work after completing the anonymous employee survey."
- A satirical job-interview post by Harvey Jutton, one of the most-liked we found on LinkedIn with about 1,700 reactions, has the interviewer boast about an "anonymous" survey that's "definitely not anonymous."
- Rajeev Peshawaria, a CEO and leadership author, told SHRM: "There is no such thing as anonymous." His point was that if management really wants to find out who said what, it can, and the difference between ethical and unethical leaders is whether they choose to.
- Consultants at Mercer Sirota told SHRM that most surveys are really "confidential" rather than anonymous, because the company receives details such as business unit and tenure alongside the answers.
Open comments give people away
Even when the ratings are safe, the written comments often aren't. People recognize each other's examples, phrases and tone.
- Bennett McEwan remembers an "anonymous" annual survey at a large health insurer. HR shared the comments without names, but in a department of about 150 people, he says he could identify who wrote every comment.
- Phakamani Ntimbane, who works in market research, puts it simply: how anonymous is a survey when your manager knows your writing style?
- Small details do the rest. Deborah Roland, an HR vice president, told SHRM that the more identifying details a company collects, the less frank the answers it gets.
The fear of what happens next
- Hallie Condon, VP of People at a software company, once ran an anonymous engagement survey and then sat in a meeting where leadership demanded to know what her team had said. Her conclusion: "A feedback culture isn't an infrastructure. It's what happens to the person who tells the truth."
- Roland told SHRM that wanting to know who said what is "human nature," especially when the feedback is negative.
- Even reminders can break trust. A Forbes advice columnist quoted by SHRM asked who would trust a survey's confidentiality after receiving a message saying "You haven't completed your survey yet."
The feeling that nothing changes
- Erin Abbey, a communications adviser, argues that employees don't have survey fatigue: they have "nothing changes fatigue."
- Andrea Jones, a Chief People Officer, says employees click "Agree" just to make the survey go away, results show up months later, nothing changes, and next year the answers get even blander.
Why surveys aren't going away
- In 2018, two people-analytics leaders at Facebook and the psychologist Adam Grant argued in Harvard Business Review that dropping surveys would be a big mistake. Their three reasons, based on Facebook's internal research: surveys are still great predictors of behavior, they give employees the chance to feel heard, and they are a vehicle for changing behavior.
- What happens after a survey is surprisingly under-studied. A 2021 review of the research on survey follow-up, by Lena-Alyeska Huebner and Hannes Zacher, concluded that there is little empirical evidence on it, and that what exists is scattered.
What HR experts suggest
- Act on what people say, and show it. This is the consensus fix, from Gallup and Perceptyx to practitioners like Abbey: decide before the survey who owns each theme, then tell people what changed.
- Collect fewer personal details. Every extra question about department, tenure or role makes answers easier to trace, and less honest.
- Have someone outside run it. Ntimbane argues that real anonymity only starts when a third party runs the survey.
- Use tools that can't trace answers. Some newer platforms, such as Canero, say they are built so that they couldn't de-anonymize an employee even if asked.
- Or talk instead. The Forbes columnist quoted by SHRM goes further: healthy organizations don't need engagement surveys, because people walk up to each other and talk.
What we did about it in Org360
We agree with most of this advice, and one part of it shaped how we built Org360. Ratings can be protected with group thresholds. Written comments can't, because you can almost always guess who wrote what from the tone, a phrase, or an example only one person would use. So in our Highest confidentiality mode, the person who runs the survey never sees the comments at all.
- Nobody can be picked out. The report only opens after 5 people have answered, and reminders go to the whole group, so nobody can see who has or hasn't replied.
- Nobody's words are read. The owner never sees a single comment as written, only an AI summary of the themes, with names and organization names removed before the text reaches the AI. There's no writing style to recognize.
- Nobody is pressured. Respondents can edit or delete their answers until the survey closes, and they're told up front how their answers will be handled.
For leaders, that's a message as much as a feature: we really want to know, and we've set it up so we can't find out who said it. Highest mode is part of the Pro plan; our guide on how confidentiality works explains every mode.
One honest caveat. No tool fixes leaders who go hunting for the culprit, or who never act on what they hear. Highest mode removes the fear of being identified. Acting on what people say is still the leaders' job.
Frequently asked questions
Why don't employees trust engagement surveys?
In a Visier survey of 1,000 US employees, the top reasons for holding back were not believing the survey is really anonymous (37%) and not believing the employer will act on the feedback (27%).
Are employee engagement surveys really anonymous?
Often not completely. Many surveys are confidential rather than anonymous: the company receives details such as department or tenure, and written comments can reveal who wrote them through tone or examples.
How can you make employees trust an engagement survey?
Act visibly on the results, collect fewer identifying details, consider having a third party run it, and use a tool that protects comments, for example by showing only a summary of them.
What is survey fatigue?
Employees stop answering surveys, or answer carelessly. Research from Perceptyx and others suggests the main cause is not the number of surveys but seeing nothing change afterwards.
Can managers see who wrote a survey comment?
In many tools the comments are shown word for word without names, which still lets colleagues recognize each other. In Org360's Highest confidentiality mode, the survey owner sees only an AI summary of the comments, never the comments themselves.
Sources
All checked on 15 November 2026. Vendors change these pages often, so check the current version before you decide.
- Visier: nearly half of employees withhold feedback (survey of 1,000 US employees, October 2024)
- Gallup: so you administered an employee engagement survey
- Perceptyx: are employee surveys effective?
- Judd, O’Rourke and Grant (2018), Employee surveys are still one of the best ways to measure engagement, Harvard Business Review
- Huebner and Zacher (2021), Following up on employee surveys: a conceptual framework and systematic review, Frontiers in Psychology
- SHRM: why do workers distrust engagement surveys? (2018)
- SHRM: how anonymous is that employee satisfaction survey? (2019)
- The anonymous survey meme (Instagram)
- Harvey Jutton on LinkedIn
- Bennett McEwan on LinkedIn
- Phakamani Ntimbane on LinkedIn
- Hallie Condon on LinkedIn
- Erin Abbey on LinkedIn
- Andrea Jones on LinkedIn
- Michael Pena on Canero (LinkedIn)
Get new research by email
About one email a month, when we publish something new on coaching, 360 feedback and engagement surveys.
We'll email you once to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. See our data protection policy.