Peer feedback: examples, and how to ask a colleague for it
Daniele D'Esposito, founder of Org360
Published , 6 min read, CC BY 4.0
In short
- Peer feedback comes from colleagues at about your level, who see how you work day to day.
- Useful peer feedback names a situation, the behavior and its effect.
- People are kinder to a colleague's face than in private, so a short confidential survey gets franker answers than a meeting.
- Ask 5 to 8 peers so at least 3 reply, and ask about work they've actually seen.
Peer feedback is feedback from colleagues who work alongside you at a similar level, about how you work with them.
What do peers see that a manager doesn't?
- How you hand work over, and whether it arrives on time.
- Whether you share information or keep it.
- How you behave in meetings your manager doesn't attend.
- How you react when a colleague questions your work.
- What you're like under a deadline.
That's why peers are part of almost every 360, and why some people run a peer-only survey.
What makes peer feedback useful?
Specifics. The Center for Creative Leadership's Situation-Behavior-Impact model is a simple structure: say when and where it happened, describe what the person did, then say what effect it had.
The examples below are ones we wrote to show the format. The people and situations are invented.
| Vague | Specific |
|---|---|
| "Great team player." | "When the copywriter dropped out before the March launch, you rewrote the onboarding emails over 2 evenings. We shipped on time because of it." |
| "Communication could be better." | "In Monday's planning meeting you agreed to the new deadline, then told your team on Thursday. They lost 3 days." |
| "A bit defensive." | "In the budget review, you answered Priya's question before she'd finished it. Nobody else asked a question after that." |
| "Really reliable." | "Every handover note you've sent me this quarter listed open issues and who to call. I've never had to chase you." |
Peer feedback examples by area
These follow the areas in our peer survey, Working With Me. Again, invented examples.
- Communication. Strength: "Your weekly update is the one I actually read: 5 lines, decisions first." To develop: "When plans change, I hear it from the client before I hear it from you."
- Collaboration. Strength: "You offered your research notes before I asked, and it saved me a week." To develop: "In joint projects you take the visible parts and leave the follow-up to others."
- Reliability and ownership. Strength: "When the invoice went out wrong, you called the client yourself the same day." To develop: "2 of the last 3 deadlines slipped without a heads-up."
- Feedback and learning. Strength: "After my comments on your draft, the next version fixed all 3 points." To develop: "When someone questions your numbers, you explain why they're right before asking what they saw."
- Respect under pressure. Strength: "During the outage you kept the channel calm and gave everyone one job." To develop: "Your messages get very short and sharp near deadlines, and juniors read them as anger."
How do you ask a colleague for feedback?
- Ask about one piece of work. "How did my part of the launch land for you?" gets a better answer than "any feedback?"
- Ask for one thing to change. "What's one thing I could do differently next time we work together?"
- Ask in writing, so they have time to think.
- Thank them, and don't argue. You can decide later what to do with it.
Face to face, most colleagues will be kind. For a fuller picture, send a short confidential survey. Working With Me has 11 rated questions and 1 open question: "What does this person do well, and what's one thing they could develop?" It takes about 5 minutes.
How do you give peer feedback in a survey?
- Rate only what you've seen. If you haven't worked with them on something, say so in your comment.
- Write one strength and one thing to develop, each with an example.
- Describe what they did, and leave out guesses about why.
What the research says
- One peer is a noisy measure, several are better. Viswesvaran, Ones and Schmidt (1996) found a mean interrater reliability of .52 for a single supervisor rating overall performance, and lower agreement among peers. Averaging several peers gives a steadier picture.
- Peers rate the same way whatever the purpose. Greguras and colleagues (2003) found that the quality of peer ratings didn't differ between development and administrative use, unlike ratings from direct reports.
- Feedback about the task works better than feedback about the self. Kluger and DeNisi (1996) found that feedback interventions more often backfired when they drew attention to the person and away from the task. That's the case for describing behavior.
- A few specific comments help most. Smither and Walker (2004) found that managers who received a small number of behavior-focused, unfavorable comments improved more than others.
Full references are in the research reading list.
Org360's view
Peer feedback is the most underused feedback at work. Peers see the most of how someone works, and they're the least likely to say it unless asked in a way that's safe. A 12-question confidential survey, sent to 5 to 8 colleagues, is the easiest way to ask.
Frequently asked questions
What is peer feedback?
Feedback from colleagues at a similar level about how you work with them, often collected as part of a 360.
What is an example of constructive peer feedback?
"In Monday's planning meeting you agreed to the new deadline, then told your team on Thursday. They lost 3 days." It names the situation, the behavior and the effect.
How many peers should I ask?
5 to 8, so at least 3 reply. With fewer than 3 replies, answers can be traced.
Is peer feedback anonymous?
In a confidential survey it is, once at least 3 peers reply. In conversation, it isn't, which is why people are kinder face to face.
Sources: CCL: Use Situation-Behavior-Impact (SBI) to understand intent
Cite this article
Org360 (2026). Peer feedback: examples, and how to ask a colleague for it. In: Honest feedback at work, the Org360 feedback guide. https://org360.app/feedback-guide/peer-feedback. Licensed under CC BY 4.0.